Thursday, September 29, 2005

The Parish and Elitism

The Parish has an enjoyable and troubling story. A highligh:
His Sunday School class probably shares many of his values if not his outspokenness, and many of them have learned to couch their prejudices in spiritual language so those ideas don't sound like racism or xenophobia or the worship of capitalist ideals.

Friday, September 16, 2005

Repubs and Mike Pence on Fiscal Responsibility

Good article and a number of good comments over at TPMCafe I don't subscribe to the Wall Street Journal so I'll have to take their word for the article. Over at the Republican Study Committee site there's an interesting document quoting RSC chairman U.S. Congressman Mike Pence (R-IN) from a speech made on the house floor on Sept 8. A highlight:

“But as we tend to the wounded, as we begin to rebuild, let us also do what every other American family would do in like circumstances and expects this Congress to do: Let’s figure out how we are going to pay for it.

“Congress must insure that a catastrophe of nature does not become a catastrophe of debt for our children and grandchildren.”


A few other interesting articles on the subject are Reckless spending is no relief, Thumbing Nervously Through the Conservative Rulebook - New York Times, and WISH-TV - Indianapolis, Indiana - Your Home of 24 Hour News, Sports, Weather & the Weatherbug - Hostettler Issues Statement on Vote Against Katrina Aid.

It's interesting that when it comes to the neocon agenda and Iraq, there's a blank check. When it comes to US domestic issues, there's a call for fiscal responsibility. Pence's words need to apply across our policies. There's no question that deficit spending is not sustainable. The people of this country and their leadership need to decide if a global empire of hundreds of bases and preemptive military policy embody who we are OR are we truly interested in peace both abroad and at home? Ethical and philosophical discussions aside, we are being irresponsible with our children's future. The disappointing aspect of Pence's comments are that they reflect immediately indicate the current philosophy in the leadership of our country- fiscal responsibility is a chance to cut domestic programs that help the least privileged in our country while enriching the already wealthy while at the same time maintaining a military that is financially speaking the size of all others in the world combined. Who needs lessons in fiscal responsibility? The discussion has become almost ridiculous at this point. We're talking about removing a the mole on our arm while ignoring the tumors spread throughout the body. We'll look a little better, but we're sick to death inside.

Wednesday, September 14, 2005

New Film

I'm looking forward to the chance to see this film screened by EthicsDaily.com. Good Quote:
“Being on the morally right side of history is always so obvious with the passage of time,” said Robert Parham, executive director of the Baptist Center for Ethics. Parham said what is needed is not only a sense of history, but also a sense of discernment about events during one’s own place and time.

Reflections on Augustine

Interesting reflection at EthicsDaily. Highlight:
Augustine understood that we cannot look to God to maintain our levees. We cannot look to God to evacuate our fellow citizens. We cannot look to God to stop the poverty and the inequality, which along with the flood waters drove the miserable and the wretched into the Convention Center and Superdome.

Tuesday, September 13, 2005

The Administration that Keeps on Giving, errr Taking

Check out this article in case you've missed the VP in all of the excitement.

Wednesday, September 07, 2005

Arrogance Repackaged

I don't want to be petty in the face of severe suffering. I hope the following is an attempt to understand part of this "American thing" we have going on here. I have heard in numerous commentaries on Katrina, most recently last night on the Al Franken show, some version of "I can't believe this is America". Sometimes it's packaged in a question, "Is this America?" A few times it's been soldiers fresh from Iraq. Sometimes it's in reference to the destruction. Sometimes it's in reference to the government's response. Something is bothering me about these questions and statements that I'm not sure I can put my finger on. When I was in SE Asia after the tsunami, I never heard the people we spoke with or read any interviews of, "I can't believe this is Thailand" or "Is this Sri Lanka" or "I couldn't believe I was in India". Don't get me wrong, people leveled criticism at their governments and those handling the response. What was lacking, however, was the American sense of, "This shouldn't happen here." I personally feel that much of the suffering and destruction could have been (and was) anticipated and some of it prevented. We have incredible human and physical resources in this country. In that sense, then yes, this shouldn't happen here. On the other hand, my skeptical side hears this kind of speech and I see another aspect to it. I see an arrogance that believes that disasters and tragedies on a large scale only happen to other people. Somehow being American in and of itself should shield us from great tragedies whether man-made or natural- Oklahoma City, 9/11, Katrina. I do know that people from other countries notice this attitude in us. Close, honest relationships can sometimes betray a guilty sense of satisfaction that now the Americans "know what it's like", "it can happen to you, too." I heard this somewhat in reverse after the tsunami. Plenty of conversations with Americans both in the US and even some working in the relief efforts would comment on how different, i.e. "better", we would plan for or respond to natural disasters "in America".

Before someone raises the complaint that this is a "America Bad-Everyone Else Good" blog, please know that's not what I'm saying at all. The comparison is just fresh in my mind. I guess I'd just like to see less arrogance from us. All of the "greatest nation" talk and "only superpower" talk and "we'll do this" and "we'll do that", "everyone did a great job", etc... I'd like to see a sense of humility. I know it's only a dream, but if the last couple years haven't taught us anything else, they should at least show us that we bleed like anyone else, we make mistakes like anyone else, we're vulnerable to attack like anyone else, we're corrupt like anyone else, the list goes on. Being "American" doesn't miraculously exempt us from mother nature or human nature. The basis for our power in the world is due to our military and nuclear arsenals. We make lots of money to go along with it, although foreigners carry most of our mortgage on the nation. For some reason we think that being the best armed and the most willing to fight carries with it a whole host of other privileges and moral superiority. Sometimes something like a tragedy and our response can reveal some of these myths for what they are.

Americans are responding to the needs of those affected by the tragedy in amazing ways- self sacrificing ways. I hope that in doing so we all gain the humility that comes from seeing our vulnerability and our humanity. Yes, tragedy can happen to us. Just like it can happen to anyone else. The sooner that doesn't surprise us, the better.

Will Our Uncle Be There When We Need Him?

I'm one of the fortunate people in this world who has had over the years several "safety nets" below me. I have a family in which every member is a support for the other. Since childhood my parents have created an environment that was supportive to the point of encouraging risk, although my mother drew the line with motorcycles and sky diving. As far as financial, professional, educational, and life-crises went, I have been blessed with the safety net of parents whose support, both physical and emotional, was always there. IN adulthood my safety net was supplemented by adult siblings with whom I have a mutual relationship that says, "Whatever it is you need, I'm there." My in-laws, too, have demonstrated the same level of security. It may sound funny coming from a middle-aged husband, father, professional male to describe this safety net, but I try not to take it for granted. I fully admit that much of the good I have in my life I did nothing to get. It is grace in the truest sense of the word. I am the undeserving recipient of unconditional love from people who are really good at giving it.

One disturbing conversation I had with my parents back in 2003 revealed that, despite the fact that they lived close to the geographic center of the continental US and far away from ANY viable terrorist target, they felt threatened and even frightened in the wake of 9/11. It was difficult for me to understand, and our conversations admittedly were not very productive. Afterward I realized that the fear generated by 9/11 went much deeper. My parent's generation, children at the time of Pearl Harbor, have built a nation in which they thought 9/11 was impossible. Add into that the color coded alert system that keeps reminding them of their vulnerability (or at least it did before the elections) and you have people who have never know a threat in their lives sitting in one of the most secure places in the world feeling a constant underlying sense of insecurity and fear. The safety net of American military strength that they believed could keep out all would-be attackers no longer exists. Decision making, especially voting, is then strongly affected by this.

A question I heard asked on the news yesterday was directed to a government official (didn't catch which one). The person was explaining that this is an unprecedented disaster and the logistics of response took time to work out. This disaster was predicted ahead of time, "war gamed" a year ago, and involves loss of life, likely on a large scale. It took a week for the resources available (military, helicopters, airboats, etc....) to be deployed. We have government officials coming close to physical contortions to avoid identifying where the breakdowns occurred. Reflecting on my own expectations of government, I am probably one of many Americans who have always had an underlying assumption of a governmental safety net that would be there if something really catastrophic happened, i.e. the government (local, state, national) would be there to step in. I can't help but wonder if much of the frustration and anger being expressed by those affected by the storm, but especially those NOT affected by the storm watching from the comfort of our homes, might have as a component of it the realization that the safety net isn't really there. I'm not debating whether or not it should be there or not, just making the point that for thousands of people it was not there. Only time will tell what affects this my have on the national psyche. Will the way local governments plan be affected by this, knowing that the feds may not be there? Will this affect where we locate? How we vote? For many of the victims of the hurricane such a discussion is a real luxury. Where they live, work, and travel involves much less freedom of choice than some of the rest of us on the outside looking in. But for those who do have choices and aren't trapped by necessity, what will we do with the revelations of the past weeks? Will Uncle Sam be there when we need him?

Tuesday, September 06, 2005

News from Unlikely Places

I didn't know this magazine existed, although I may subscribe just to be able to put it in the bathroom magazine rack, but thanks to Todd Gitlin's reference to this article in Solid Waste and Recycling Magazine. National and cultural skeletons (racism, classism, beaurocratic power plays) are getting trotted into the light as a result of Katrina. Now our environmental policy may join the crowd.

Saturday, September 03, 2005

Letter from Gov Blanco

Here's the disaster relief request from Gov Blanco to the President. Note it's addressed to the White House.

Anne Lamott

Friday, September 02, 2005

Greg Palast and "America's Stubborn Historical Amnesia"

Great quote by Greg Palast :
A pedagogical note: As I travel around the USA, I'm just horrified at America's stubborn historical amnesia. Americans, as Sam Cooke said, don't know squat about history. We don't learn the names of a nation's capitol until the 82d Airborne lands there. And it doesn't count if you've watched a Ken Burns documentary on PBS.

I suggest starting with this: read "Huey Long" by the late historian Harry T. Williams. If you want to ease into it, get the Randy Newman album based on it (Good Old Boys) with the song, "Louisiana 1927." Do NOT watch the crappy right-wing agit-prop film, "Huey Long," by Ken Burns.

Thursday, September 01, 2005

Tragedy and Politics

Have any of us ever heard of Latoyia Figueroa?

Excellent article by Miguel De La Torre at Ethics Daily.com highlighting the segregation of the media and its almost total caucasian bias.
Journalism today is one of the nation’s most segregated professions. According to the American Society of Newspaper Editors, only 5 percent of reporters are black while 45 percent of this nation’s newsrooms have no person of color.
He tactfully introduces the article by comparing the handling of the Natalee Holloway case versus another disappearance at the same time, that of Latoyia Figueroa. I personally would add that the media's obsession with the Holloway case is probably hightened even more by the fact that her alleged obductors are persons of color.